Should You Opt Out of Google's AI Overviews? One Site Tried It and Lost About 21% of Its Clicks
One site opted out of Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode for 28 days and lost an estimated 21% of its Google clicks. Here's what the test showed, how Google's October link changes raise the stakes, and who should still opt out.

Short answer: for most brands, no. When SEO consultant Cyrus Shepard took his site out of AI Overviews and AI Mode for 28 days in September, he estimated those features had been sending about 21% of its Google clicks, and his regular organic clicks dipped as well. Since then, Google's October 15 update has added more links to AI answers and placed them higher, which makes leaving even harder to justify. Opting out still makes sense for a small group of publishers whose content is the product, but even large news publishers are holding off until Google shares click data.
The opt-out in brief
Since August 31, 2026, every site worldwide has had a Search Console setting that keeps its content out of Google's generative AI features (Google). It started as a UK requirement from the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) and Google then opened it to everyone. Before deciding, know what it does and does not touch:
- It covers AI Overviews, AI Mode and the generative AI features in Discover.
- It is site-wide: You can't pick individual features or pages yet. Page-level controls are due by March 3, 2027 under the UK rules.
- It is not a ranking signal: Google says regular search results are unaffected.
- It does not control training: Use of your content to train Gemini is managed separately through Google-Extended.
- It does not affect other engines: ChatGPT, Perplexity and Copilot follow their own crawlers and rules.
News publishers have one more thing to check. NewzDash found Top Stories carousels showing inside AI Overviews on about one in six US trending news results, and NewzDash's John Shehata expects the opt-out to remove publishers from those placements too (Search Engine Journal). Google has not confirmed how the setting treats them.
What one site lost when it opted out
Until recently, the cost of opting out was a guess. Cyrus Shepard, founder of Zyppy SEO, turned it into a number by testing it on his own site (Search Engine Journal). He opted zyppy.com out on September 1, opted back in on September 29, and compared the two 28-day periods.
- AI impressions vanished in under an hour and came back almost as fast after he opted back in.
- AI features were about 10% of the site's impressions, roughly 500 to 1,000 a day.
- Those impressions clicked at about 0.9%, compared with 0.4% for the site across Google Search as a whole.
- That added up to about 21% of the site's Google clicks.
- Regular organic clicks fell too: Shepard saw a small lift in organic click-through when the site appeared in AI answers, mostly on the pages with the most AI visibility. Counting that, he ties about 23% of the site's search clicks to Google's AI features.
The most useful finding is the click-through rate. A common assumption is that AI impressions are low-value views that rarely lead to a visit. On this site, they produced clicks at more than twice the rate of everything else.
Shepard is clear about the limits. It is one site, it had done a lot of work to earn AI citations, and the click figures are his estimates because Search Console mixes AI clicks with regular ones. Other sites could see a higher or lower share. His own conclusion was to stay opted in.
Google's October 15 change raises the cost of leaving
Shepard's test ran in September. On October 15, Google changed how links appear in AI Overviews and AI Mode (Google):
- More inline links, placed higher: Google says it has substantially increased the links embedded in AI responses and will show them higher up more often.
- Better related-article links: Links at the end of some answers now carry image thumbnails and a larger click area.
- Wider news carousels: Carousels for timely articles are expanding to more countries and languages and highlight a searcher's Preferred Sources. Google says use of Preferred Sources has grown more than 7x since the start of 2026.
- An official websites section (in testing) that puts one or two official sites for a task at the top of the answer.
- Clickable creator names (in testing) on video results in AI Mode, linking to the creator's Search profile.
Google did not publish click data with the update, so there is no proof yet that these links send more traffic. The direction matters anyway. Every change on that list makes a cited site more visible inside the answer, and an opted-out site is excluded from all of them. If the 21% figure was measured before these links got more prominent, the cost of leaving is unlikely to have gone down since.
Where the Search Console AI report fits
Search Console's generative AI report shows impressions in AI Overviews, AI Mode and Discover by page, country and device, but still no clicks or queries. On November 2, Google's Gary Illyes said the team had nothing to announce on adding them (Search Engine Roundtable). Under the CMA rules, Google must give UK publishers clicks and click-through rates for its AI features from December 3, 2026 (CMA). That data, if it arrives, will make the opt-out decision far easier to make with evidence. Tracking AI referral traffic on your own site is a separate job, covered in our guide to the GA4 AI channel.
Who should still consider opting out
Opting out trades visibility for control. It can still be the right call when:
- Your content is the product: News, reference, recipe and data publishers whose revenue depends on page views or subscriptions may find that an AI answer replaces the visit rather than leading to one.
- Your licensing terms require it: If your content is licensed elsewhere on terms that rule out free AI use, the setting may be a contractual necessity, not a traffic decision.
- You have a specific reason to keep your content out of AI summaries, such as regulated or time-sensitive information where a summary could misstate it.
Even in these cases, the big players are moving slowly. Digiday reported on November 9 that publishers are holding off until click data arrives, and none of the publishers it named, including The Economist Group, the Daily Mail and Reuters, had opted out (Digiday). Publishers are also asking the CMA to let them opt out of individual features, which the current all-or-nothing setting does not allow.
Who should stay in
For brands, B2B companies, SaaS vendors, e-commerce sites and service providers, content exists to get the business found. AI Overviews and AI Mode are increasingly where buyers form shortlists. Opting out removes you from those answers while competitors stay in, and you lose the chance to shape how your category is described. Shepard's halo finding adds a second cost: appearing in the AI answer may also help your regular listing get the click.
Example: a mid-size HR software company sees its comparison and pricing pages cited in AI answers for queries like best HR software for 200 employees. Opting out would protect nothing it sells, would hand those answers to competitors, and, if Shepard's numbers are anywhere near typical, would cost it a meaningful share of its Google clicks. Staying in and improving the pages Google already cites is the better bet.
Before you flip the switch
- Be clear on what your content does for you: If it is the product, AI answers may compete with you. If it is marketing, AI answers distribute it.
- Check your news exposure: If you publish news, assume opting out may also cost you Top Stories placements inside AI Overviews until Google says otherwise.
- Remember it is site-wide: Until page-level controls arrive in 2027, you can't protect a paywalled section and keep your product pages in. Older tools such as nosnippet work per page but also limit regular snippets.
- Wait for click data if you can: UK publishers are due clicks and click-through rates from December 3. Deciding after that is cheaper than deciding before.
- Keep any test short: If you do try it, set an end date. Zyppy's AI impressions returned within hours of opting back in, but every opted-out day is traffic you don't get back.
- Decide per engine: Opting out of Google's AI features leaves your visibility in ChatGPT, Perplexity and Copilot unchanged.
The bottom line
The opt-out gives site owners real control over Google's AI features, and the first public test shows what that control can cost: about a fifth of one site's Google clicks, plus a small dip in regular organic clicks. Google's October link changes push the same way. For most companies that market through content, the better move is to stay in and work on earning citations. Opting out remains a tool for businesses whose content is the product, and even they are waiting for Google's click data before using it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Methodology & Sourcing
Data Accuracy & AI Visibility Metrics:The statistics and AI visibility scores cited in this article are generated using Hordus AI's proprietary Answer Share of Voice (A-SOV) engine. Data is derived from consented, anonymized real user interactions across major LLM interfaces (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini).
Editorial Integrity:All AI-assisted research undergoes mandatory human editorial review by our GEO strategy team prior to publication to ensure factual accuracy and alignment with Google's YMYL (Your Money or Your Life) search quality rater guidelines.